The press as a watchdog of the people: Revisiting a theoretical triad

Abstract

In political science there are two broadly contending perspectives on the factors of democratisation: structural and values-oriented. In journalism discourse the structural perspective is reflected in the considerable literature on the roles of the press as a watchdog of government and business, in the sense of keeping watch on these entities. Not as formally articulated is the role of the press as a watchdog of the people, i.e. as critics of societal values with a bearing on the course of democracy. This article attempts to fill this gap by examining the actual and potential role of the press in bringing about values transformation in newly democratising countries. It is noted that the African press's orientation to coverage of civic and political issues emphasises the structural dimensions, especially deficits in leadership and the political process. Yet, in most cases related societal values warrant critical press coverage. It is argued that the African press will further...